Since the site is run by Goodwill, they actually have the items they're selling, take pictures of each before they go up for sale, and list background information you can actually trust—as opposed to someone else's photos or some stock photo instead of the real thing. As with most Hive Five posts, if your favorite was left out, it didn't get the nominations required in the call for contenders post to make the top five.
The company has been a labor of love since 1999, is a small business with a handful of dedicated employees, and it's been chugging along, making both classic and modern game fans happy ever since. Read more in its nomination thread here. Those of you who nominated eStarland called out those latter points specifically in its nomination thread, and it's worth noting that if you do live in the area, you can pick up online orders at the brick and mortar store as well.
Compare Swappa vs GameStop and see that we actually appreciate gamers. In the nomination thread, many of you noted that Glyde's sales and buying process are remarkably easy and painless, and their customer service has been known to bend over backwards to resolve disputes and help people out. The Hive Five is based on reader nominations. On a personal note, a few years back I picked up The Fallout Trilogy (the first three games, mind you, Fallout, Fallout 2, and Fallout: Tactics) on DVD for something like a buck, and Far Cry 2 for something like three dollars—all at my local Goodwill. Whether it's online at ShopGoodwill.com or in a brick-and-mortar store, it's no surprise that Goodwill is a great place for deals on used video games and consoles—both old and new. Buy Refurbished Sony PlayStation 4 1TB Slim Gaming Console …
You turned in tons of great suggestions, from the local to the international. Their interface may not be the easiest when it comes to looking specifically for used games and consoles, but they do have them for sale from individual sellers and Amazon Merchants who are more than happy to offer great discounts over the same products new. They don't sell consoles (at least, not yet), so you won't find a use PS 2 to go with the games they have for sale, for example, but they do have tons of games listed and plenty of people selling their old games there. You can sell your games at the same time too. When you do your spring cleaning, you're undoubtedly going to come across things that you want to…. Buying used means you get the best deal on video games and gear. When you can pick up a new SNES for around $50, or sell your own old consoles and games directly to the site (they don't just take any trade-in though—you can learn more here) for resale, it makes sense they're a diamond in the rough of used game sales.